7th Circuit Says Exhaustion of Remedies No ‘Scavenger Hunt’ – Update for February 4, 2022

We post news and comment on federal criminal justice issues, focused primarily on trial and post-conviction matters, legislative initiatives, and sentencing issues.

SCAVENGER HUNT FOR BP-9 UNNECESSARY

Eric Gooch filed a Bivens action in December 2019 against two correctional officers, claiming an 8th Amendment violation after they allegedly convinced another inmate to attack him. Under the Prison Litigation Reform Act, an inmate has to exhaust all available administrative remedies before he or she can sue.

snitch160802Eric did not, claiming that when he asked his counselor for a remedy form, the counselor refused to give him one, saying “I’m not giving you a form to file on that and you better watch out snitching on staff.”

The District Court dismissed his lawsuit, holding that Eric could have mailed his request “directly to the Regional Office, as the regulations and program statement provide.” Thus, the administrative remedy process was still “available” to Eric, so he had to exhaust all of its steps before filing a complaint in federal court.

Last week, the 7th Circuit reversed the dismissal. The Circuit held that exhaustion of administrative remedies is not required when the prison officials responsible for providing grievance forms refuse to give a prisoner the forms necessary to file an administrative grievance. Evidence of the appropriate official’s refusal to give a prisoner an available form is sufficient to permit a finding that the administrative remedies are not available.

scavenger220204The 7th said that under the plain language of the BOP’s administrative-remedy process rules, in order to submit a grievance to the Warden or Regional Director, a prisoner must use the appropriate BP-9 form. The BOP argued that Eric had time remaining to file a timely BP-9, so he should have tried harder to procure the BP-9 form — for instance, by asking other staff — before “rushing to court.” The Circuit rejected this as “unworkable,” holding that the PLRA does require “prisoners to go on scavenger hunts just to take the first step toward filing a grievance.”

Gooch v. Young, Case No. 21-1702, 2022 U.S. App. LEXIS 2042 (7th Cir., January 24, 2022)

– Thomas L. Root

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *